Statement on progressive Rabbis at ‘National March for Hostages’

Yesterday, at a march in central London advertised as a “National March for the Hostages” – the UK’s most senior progressive rabbis, Rabbi Charley Baginsky and Rabbi Josh Levy, were told to leave the stage. They highlighted the protests in Israel calling for an end to the war. A few individuals shouted “no deal”. The rabbis then made the point that Palestinians have the right to self-determination, and tried to continue their speech, but were heckled by some and removed from the stage by the organisers from the group “Stop the Hate”.

“Stop the Hate” doesn’t seem to practice what it preaches.

As the two rabbis pointed out, most Israelis want this war to end and for a deal that will free all hostages. This is the broad consensus among hostage families in Israel.

Surely our community must listen to what the families are saying, listen to what survivors of captivity have said, and understand that the continued war puts the hostages at risk.

Unity is important, but not at the cost of placating extremists. The focus now should not be on the rabbis who spoke, but on those who silenced them. The only people who should have felt unwelcome at this rally were those who called against a deal to free the hostages.

Our community leaders need to step up and be clear on where they stand. They have always said that they support a two state solution, which assumes Palestinian self determination. Why is the sheer mention of Palestinian statehood being treated as so controversial?

At a time like this, our community needs leadership. This cannot be shrugged off, and we hope that our community leaders are asking serious questions about what happened yesterday and how they will ensure it doesn’t happen again.

MK Rabbi Gilad Kariv, Chairman of the Knesset Committee for Immigration, Absorption and Diaspora Affairs, made the following statement:

“The culture of debate and the ability to unite around a common goal, even amid differing opinions, are the secret of the Jewish people’s strength – in Israel and in Jewish communities around the world.

The shameful removal of the leaders of liberal and Reform Judaism in the UK from the stage at a rally for the hostages in London is a violent and cowardly act.

Just as many Israeli citizens oppose the government’s policies as part of the struggle to bring the hostages home, so too do many in communities across the Jewish world.

I intend to invite the two rabbis to remotely participate in a meeting of the Knesset’s Immigration, Absorption, and Diaspora Affairs Committee, where we will listen to their full remarks with an open mind and with the utmost respect.

We will not agree to the silencing of voices – not in Israel and not in Jewish communities around the world. We will continue to stand together against extremists.”